The news, 365 days behind — on purpose Delayed live · replaying 2025

One Year Ago.AI

Remember how fast this is.

17OCT2024replayed
one year on
productAdobe

Adobe demos AI tool that rotates 2D vector art in 3D

The image-rotation demo uses AI to fill in gaps when rotating flat vector images, creating convincing 3D views while preserving the 2D aesthetic.

Adobe today unveiled Project Turnable, a technology demonstration that uses AI to rotate 2D vector art in three dimensions while maintaining the artwork’s flat, illustrated appearance. The tool was shown at the company’s MAX conference as part of its annual ‘Sneaks’ segment, where engineers present experimental ideas that may never ship.

Created by Adobe research scientist Zhiqin Chen, the image-rotation demo allows users to rotate flat vector graphics to any angle. As the image spins, the AI fills in gaps — for example, a horse drawn with only two visible legs appears to grow its hidden legs when rotated. The result remains a flat 2D image that looks correct from the new angle. Adobe’s Brian Domingo told Creative Bloq that while there is no guarantee of commercial release, the team expects significant interest from the MAX audience.

The demo quickly climbed to the top of Hacker News, gathering 912 points and 268 comments. While many commenters praised the tool as a sensible application of AI — solving a genuine pain point rather than forcing AI into unrelated products — others expressed skepticism. Some noted that Adobe has a history of flashy demos that never become features, pointing to previous hype cycles around blockchain and NFTs. A few commenters suggested that even unreleased features can boost sales by impressing executives and investors, regardless of how useful they prove to actual designers.

H
HN user ryandrake

Argues this is the right way to develop AI products: find a user need that can't easily be solved with traditional methods, then build AI to solve it, rather than starting with AI and searching for a problem.

H
HN user dmurray

Suggests Adobe faces the same investor-hype pressure as other tech firms, but happens to specialize in image editing where generative AI currently performs well, and notes Adobe's past hype-chasing with blockchain and NFTs.

H
HN user TheOtherHobbes

Reminds readers that the article says there's no guarantee of release, compares it to Photoshop's Generative Fill which has been underwhelming and comically wrong, and suggests Adobe doodles with code rather than delivering robust production features.

H
HN user DowagerDave

Claims that even unshipped AI features have real value because discussing them with prospects materially impacts sales funnel costs.

One year later — open only if you can handle spoilers

As of October 17, 2024, Project Turnable had been demonstrated at Adobe MAX as a 'Sneaks' concept with no guarantee of commercial release. The HN debate reflected a broader tension between enthusiasm for practical AI applications and skepticism about Adobe's track record of shipping experimental features.

Replay thisPost on XRedditHNLinkedIn

The Weekly Replay · free by email

This week, one year ago — every Sunday.

One email each Sunday: the week's replayed AI news, with the one-year-later annotations included. Written like it's breaking — dated like it isn't.

Free · double opt-in · unsubscribe anytime · privacy